Both are tools to programmatically and easily configure Weblogic domains and servers. Why these tools?
- to automate Weblogic servers and domain creation for large scale production environment. Configuring a Weblogic domain through the administration console is tedious and slow in a multiserver environment.
- Repeat a complex configuration from server to server.
Well, you could use Java and JMX or do some reverse engineeringon some Weblogic class (like domain creation) but it would reallybe a waste of time, when tools exist to make domain administration easier.
- Jython (Python Implementation in Java) based powerful Object Oriented scripting language. You can create your own classes like creating a Security classes to add a user,a group return all the users of a domain…
- Offline capabilites to create and configure domains.
- Has functions for Weblogic Workshop.
- Learning curve of Jython/Python for more advanced coding logic.( But I have to admit that Python is easy to learn).
- type conversion between Java and python which can be annoying. Example:
- Some MBeans are hidden. Example: can not invoke methods on the DeployerRuntime MBean like the invoke method. Maybe authors want users to use the dedicated deployment functions like deploy() undeploy() instead.
- Can only use a property file to pass parameters to the script (but you could import the wlst jython module and process jython command line arguments the traditionnal way)
- Easy to learn very much like Unix SHELL.
- Aditionnal tools: provide a graphical MBean (and cli) explorer + a graphical monitoring tool.
- Can pass any kind of parameter to the script from the command line.
- Not officially supported by BEA. Some bugs exist “it returns null when trying to get some MBean”. But the author said a new version will be released for Weblogic server 9.
- Limited scripting capabilities. Language is limited (with limited control structures)
To conclude, both are not really mature tools and have some light bugs but they greatly help in Weblogic configuration tasks. I don’t know if Websphere or Oracle9iAS have this kind of tool but they represent a great advantage for Weblogic. Especially for ISVs who want to help clients to configure a Weblogic server to run their application.
Both tools can also convert an existing domain configuration (config.xml) to a script which is a very helpful feature. I think that for advanced Weblogic administration scripting wlst looks better (I chose to use it now). On the other side some features of wlsh like the MBean explorer, the graphical MBean attributes monitoring are really great. Porting wlst to Groovy scripting language ( Java based scripting language with a JSR) would also have been a great idea since it would avoid to learn another language (i.e python) but just the syntax of Groovy.